MMTM at WordPress.
Where it all began.

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

A crazy little thing called making up my own mind...

That picture is of me being dragged up to the door of Hagrid's cabin, before going on the Hippogriff ride inside of The Wizarding World of Harry Potter.  I went there without ever having even cracked the spine of one of the books.  Without ever watching one of the movies.

I know, it's some kind of travesty.

So why did I go?  For the love of Kearsie.  You see, she was visiting Florida and made plans to go there.  So Winn was going to join her, as well as our friend, Carrie.  As badly as I wanted to see Kearsie, I wasn't going to go because of the price of the tickets and the fact that it was Harry Potter and I really didn't think I would have a good time.  Then Carrie got us a super sweet deal on the tickets, and I decided to tag along.

Even though it was 103 MILLION degrees outside and I was hotter than fiendfyre, I had the best. time. ever.  It was so much fun!  The main ride? The Forbidden Journey?  If you've been on any Universal ride, it's like that, only amplify it by about a gazillion because it's so good.  But I have to say, you won't have as much fun as I did because when you go, you won't have Kearsie laughing throughout the entire ride.  And for your sake, I hope that you stop screaming at just the right moment so you don't have acromantula venom sprayed into your mouth.

Anyway.  It was all kinds of awesome.

I knew that I had some friends who were a little eensy teensy weensy bit ticked that I got to go without ever having experienced anything Harry Potter prior to that point.  Well, other than being in the room when The Husband watched the movies when they were on ABC Family.  (Which, at the time, made me less interested, because when I looked up, one of the first things I saw was Dolores Umbridge, who is scarier than an Oompa Loompa.)

I had never read the books because of one thing: witchcraft.  In other words, I drank the conservative Christian Kool-Aid.  I didn't think that my friends who had read the books were big fat sinners or anything, because I believe that everyone has to decide for themselves on those things -- yet I hadn't decided for myself.

So after being intrigued by the WWOHP at Universal, and seeing the excitement of my friends at the park and hearing them talk about it, I borrowed the books from a friend.

And I finished them all in one week.

Ho.Ly.Cow.  THEY WERE SO GOOD!!!  Why didn't anyone tell me that they were so amazing?!  They probably thought I would dunk them in a barrel full of holy water or something.

So the books were excellent.

And what about the witchcraft?  The sorcery?

Well... As I read, I wondered to myself, "Why is good magic done by Gandalf the wizard in Lord Of The Rings okay, but good magic done by Dumbledore the wizard not?"  Or, "Why is it okay for the kids in Narnia to go through a magical wardrobe to an enchanted world, but it's not okay for Harry Potter and friends to go through a magical train platform to one?"

To me, there isn't a difference.  Magic is magic, and fiction is fiction.  

In discussing this with other moms, one asked me how I would talk to my kids about the books, seeing as witchcraft is real and, in our opinion, not good.

That made me think... There are real princesses, but I don't think their lives are like Cinderella's or Aurora's.  There are real pirates, but they don't go around with parrots on their shoulders saying "Arrr, matey!"  Also, most of the Barbie movies I have seen (and I have seen my share) include some kind of magic.  Tinkerbell is still pretty popular, and that's got all the changes of seasons being brought about by pixie dust rather than the hand of God.

So if I were to say that Harry Potter is off limits because of the magical element, then I would have to eliminate a ton of books and movies from our collection.

As for me and my house, as long as I feel that my girls can differentiate fact from fiction, and as long as I feel that they are not being led astray by the things they are reading and watching, I think Harry Potter will be welcome in our home.  Especially since... Well, I'm going to give my opinion on something, but because it would be something of a spoiler, I'm going to type it in white.  If you've read the books, you can read it.  If you haven't read them or have just watched the movies, don't highlight the next part: *Especially since, in my humble opinion, I can relate the story in Harry Potter to the fight between good and evil that we are all battling, the struggle with free will, and even the story of salvation -- hello, one man giving his life for the good of all mankind?! -- I think even better than I can with The Lord of the Rings.*

That's my story and I'm sticking to it.

15 comments:

From Tracie said...

Okay. You have convinced me. I am going to read them. You told me the other night and I was all like, "yeah, I'll have to check them out one day" blah blah. But I'm really going to do it.

Thomas will be so excited.

Now...things you did not tell me the other night. You went with Kersie? My new blog-best-friend-soul-mate Kersie? I am so jealous!

Kersie. I love you. I will read Harry Potter for you and Vanessa....and my husband.

That is all.

Also-it is a major act of self-control not to highlight that. But I am a firm believer in not knowing what happens first, so I am restraining myself. IT.IS.HARD to restrain myself.

Angie said...

For as much as I read I have never been interested in touching a Harry Potter novel. You may have convinced me to at least pick one up. I still have very strong doubts that I will like it.

I am not really *into* that kind of book (magic or vampires those sorts of crazy LOL)

Look how cute you are in that picture!

Marisa Hopkins said...

I am SO glad you decided to read them and LOVED them!! I'm a pretty huge fan (and insanely jealous of you all for going to the theme park!!!)

Sara said...

A long time ago, when I was single and living in Charlotte, my AMAZING pastor did a series. It was called "Jesus Goes to the Movies" or something like that. Harry Potter was the first movie he discussed (I had not seen/ read anything yet). His theory? Same as yours. Everyone can decide what works best for them and their family. And that it WAS about good vs. evil, and the power of choosing correctly...

I heart Harry Potter. JK Rowling is my hero. My kids will be reading these books, when appropriate.

And I will fight my in- laws tooth and nail about it, and it will be SO WORTH IT.

I'm glad you had fun, and I'm only moderately jealous :)

Just Cherish Today said...

Im not much of a harry potter fan, lovedd the twilight series tho! :)

Im your newest follower, come follow me back and let's keep in touch! Thanks! :)

Michelle Hoad said...

Amen, sista. Why couldn't you have written this post a few years ago when I was trying to justify why I let my kid read them and my church friends said I was a horrible mother because I did.

Snuggle Wasteland said...

People like you give Conservative Christians a good name.

I still haven't gotten around to reading the books. I always seem to start something else first.

Mandi Miller said...

I've never really been into Harry Potter either but for other reasons... it's just not my thing. Twilight? I am with you on that one!!

Glad you had a good time!

MiMi said...

I wanna know what you think about Twilight!
One of the big dudes from the big central part of our church HATES it. Like did a whole thing on it.
Anyway. I say, okay, if you're 13 maybe I can see not reading it...but I'm 33 and have something that a lot of kids don't...DISCERNMENT.

Patricia Singleton said...

I read all of the Harry Potter books and have seen all the movies and loved them. I think magic is important in our lives just like miracles. Without magic and miracles where is the awesomeness of life supposed to be? I passed my Harry Potter books on to my daughter and she loaned me her Twilight books. I haven't been able to make myself sit down to read the first of the series. I saw the first movie and was so bored I didn't watch it all.

Sara @ Domestically Challenged said...

well said. It can become a very fuzzy line can't it? what is right/"wrong" and good/bad. I think your perspective is great!

Angelia Sims Hardy said...

I haven't read Harry but loved Twilight. I heard all the mumbo jumbo too. I've been made to feel guilty for loving sci fi. Here is how I see it. Mary was supernaturally made pregnant. Angels are supernatural beings. Jesus supernaturally rose from the dead. Everything is a battle between good and evil and there is always a savior. Pretty cool eh? Sounds like a sci fi flick to me.

Glad you had a great day and opened your mind.

:-)

Kearsie said...

I am so glad to know you. And I'm so glad you picked up the HP books. And I'm so glad you came to the theme park to hang out with me (and Winn and Carrie). And I'm so glad for myspace, where I rediscovered how awesome you are. And I'm so glad that there is a sun. Or suns. Or, well, you know.

shortmama said...

I havent read any of the HP books either, but have seen a couple of the movies. The books are on my very long list of books to read.

I completely agree with you on the witchcraft in them...even if they are based on something that is real, the books themselves are still fiction. And its our job as parents to teach our kids the difference

hotpants™ said...

I'm so glad you loved them because they are amazing!

The author had some interesting things to say about the religious aspect on Oprah. You should try to find a clip online.